Address: 34 Tower Street
Price: $749,000
The Results: The biggest vote-getter, with more than 38 percent of the tally, was $850,000. The correct asking came in second—but just barely: $749K received 24 percent of the vote and $997K received 22 percent.
In other words, a goodly number of readers went long on this 2,000-square-foot 3-BR, 3-BA with a heated garage and a price-chop on the Fourth of July of $40,000.